How to reduce membership churn


The Inner Circle Newsletter #007

Last month I spent five days in Puerto Rico at John Meese's Authority Guild mastermind. I came home with seven lessons, and today I want to share the one I'd bet matters most for your community (the other six are in a video, link below).

Most of us in the community game want the same thing: recurring revenue.

But a lot of our offers don't set us up for it. The biggest enemy of recurring revenue is churn, so the real work is designing for retention from day one.

One of the most common models is one of the worst at it. It's the Q&A community: people join to get in line and ask you questions. It feels like value, but the reality is your members are gonna run out of questions pretty quickly.

One member of the group shared the problem she had with her membership community.
​
Her one-time program is doing amazing: a program for moms with morning sickness

But she struggled with a continuity community for birth and postpartum after.

The problem was continuity ran on advice. After a few months it was hard to keep anyone.

Members got in line, asked their questions and churned, because those questions were finite and repetitive. Advice has an end, and so does the reason to keep paying.

So we talked about repositioning the continuity as an identity community. Instead of a place to get answers, what if it was a community for becoming the best mom you can be? Nobody ever finishes that.

Here's what high retention looks like. Think of a running club. It doesn't sell running advice, it sells being a runner: the Saturday long run, the race you train for together, and the new longest distance and PRs you hit, the times you run even when you don't feel like it. There's no last question to ask.

To design yours:

  • Put a transformational door in front of your membership. Members who get a real win first walk into your continuity already becoming someone.
  • Name who your members are becoming. If the honest reason they join is "to get my questions answered," you're on a clock.
  • Give that identity a ritual: a weekly thing members do together and leave better for.
  • Give your longest members a role, like welcoming the new ones. People don't quit a place where they'd be missed.

That's one takeaway from the event. The other six are in the full video.

​Watch all seven lessons from a $20k mastermind on YouTube​

We all want recurring revenue. It comes from members who stay, so give them someone to become, not just questions to ask.

Make it an epic week ✌️

Jordan

P.S. The video ends with a question for you: which lesson hits your business hardest? Hit reply and tell me.

👇 This is 1 email a week. I post more useful tips here 👇

675 Allegheny Dr, Sun City Center, FL 33573

​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

The Inner Circle

Actionable insights from the trenches of 150+ paid communities and working 1:1 with top creators in the world. Top Circle Expert.

Read more from The Inner Circle

The Inner Circle Newsletter #008 Coming to you today from sunny Santa Barbara, CA ☀️ 2026 has been a life changing year for one of our clients, Dr. Austin Cohen. Austin is a chiropractor with 16 years of experience and runs 13 locations. He’s mastered the game of chiropractic, and wanted to help others do the same. But he had a problem, he was not a “marketer” or professional creator, and didn’t know how to package his expertise to sell it online. He also didn’t have much of an audience. So...

The Inner Circle Newsletter #006 Last week a prospect told me they were probably "too small to work with us". This is definitely the case with some (usually people with no audience), but it's usually us saying that, not the prospect. So I dug in to find out why they thought that, and was stunned by their answer. On paper they were exactly who we want to help. They were already selling to their own audience, making $20k/mo, without ads. But when they looked at our client list, they saw the...

The Inner Circle Newsletter #005 Last week I was looking back at the first community product I ever sold, a community-powered course for $197, and the painful mistake that took months to fix. Here's the mistake and what it taught me: I copied someone else's model. I had followed Justin Welsh for a while and purchased his courses. I saw how successful he was and admired his business. He sold a self-paced course for one low price, and it worked really well for him, so I priced mine the same...