Are your testimonials scaring off buyers? (mine were)


The Inner Circle Newsletter #006

Last week a prospect told me they were probably "too small to work with us".

This is definitely the case with some (usually people with no audience), but it's usually us saying that, not the prospect. So I dug in to find out why they thought that, and was stunned by their answer.

On paper they were exactly who we want to help.

They were already selling to their own audience, making $20k/mo, without ads. But when they looked at our client list, they saw the big-name creators we've worked with and decided we weren't for them.

Their exact reasoning was "because you work with Ali [Abdaal] and Justin [Welsh] lol".

My first thought was, "wow, I didn't think I was turning people away with my authority."

The names I share to build trust were potentially telling the exact buyers I want to help that they didn't belong. Social proof only works when the reader can see themselves in it.

This isn't only our problem. If you run a paid community offer, you could be doing the same thing.

You lead with your biggest member win, your best-known member, or the testimonial with the largest result, because it feels like the strongest proof you have.

To someone who's just getting started, it can read like a room they aren't ready for yet.

(this is why we recently dropped the name "The $100k/mo Club" because someone who 'only' wants $20-50k/mo might feel it's not the place for them, even though it is.)

Here's how to check your own proof:

  • Read your sales page and ask who the reader would picture themselves next to. If every story is a big outcome from someone far ahead, add one from a member who started where your buyer is now.
  • Ask your newest members what almost stopped them from joining. If they say they weren't sure they were ready, your proof is aimed too high.
  • Keep the big names. Put an ordinary story right next to them, so both kinds of buyer find someone who looks like them.

What I'm working on next:

Releasing a case study of one of our top current clients, Austin, a chiropractor who went from $0 to $54k/mo in revenue with us in less than a year with his new coaching program, The Ascent.

Oh, and he had a tiny audience of less than 3k emails and less than 5k on instagram.

But what he DID have was massive expertise and a willingness to do the work. So we productized his expertise and launched a new coaching program on Circle in April of this year.

My hope is a LOT more people in my audience will see his story and think "woah, that's just like my situation and the level I'm trying to get to in the next year".

We all want to look credible. The proof that sells best shows your prospect someone who started right where they are.

Make it an epic week ✌️

Jordan

P.S. I'm trying something new. We've gotten really good at finding the bottlenecks in our client's businesses, and helping them fix them.

If you aren't sure what's holding you back, and want me to take a look, I've opened up a few spots for a free Community Business Audit 👈

Check it out and see if you qualify.

👇 This is 1 email a week. I post more useful tips here 👇

675 Allegheny Dr, Sun City Center, FL 33573

​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

The Inner Circle

Actionable insights from the trenches of 150+ paid communities and working 1:1 with top creators in the world. Top Circle Expert.

Read more from The Inner Circle

The Inner Circle Newsletter #008 Coming to you today from sunny Santa Barbara, CA ☀️ 2026 has been a life changing year for one of our clients, Dr. Austin Cohen. Austin is a chiropractor with 16 years of experience and runs 13 locations. He’s mastered the game of chiropractic, and wanted to help others do the same. But he had a problem, he was not a “marketer” or professional creator, and didn’t know how to package his expertise to sell it online. He also didn’t have much of an audience. So...

The Inner Circle Newsletter #007 Last month I spent five days in Puerto Rico at John Meese's Authority Guild mastermind. I came home with seven lessons, and today I want to share the one I'd bet matters most for your community (the other six are in a video, link below). Most of us in the community game want the same thing: recurring revenue. But a lot of our offers don't set us up for it. The biggest enemy of recurring revenue is churn, so the real work is designing for retention from day...

The Inner Circle Newsletter #005 Last week I was looking back at the first community product I ever sold, a community-powered course for $197, and the painful mistake that took months to fix. Here's the mistake and what it taught me: I copied someone else's model. I had followed Justin Welsh for a while and purchased his courses. I saw how successful he was and admired his business. He sold a self-paced course for one low price, and it worked really well for him, so I priced mine the same...